Thursday, October 2, 2014

Literary Analysis: "The Ones Who Walk Away From Omelas"

      In "The Ones Who Walk Away From Omelas", Ursula Le Guin describes a seemingly flawless city and reveals its corruption. The beautiful city appears to have none of the negative aspects that often engulf societies, but they have one dark and disgusting secret, they have locked a child away from the outside in order to keep their happiness. Through the use of a heaven like setting, situational irony, and symbolism Le Guin highlights the selfishness that many people have in order to be happy.
      Le Guin uses a glorious setting to explain that this city is perfect externally, but has a dark internal secret. The city has a beautiful bay, mountains encircle the city, and each street and each house is physically perfect. The in depth detail of the setting contributes to Le Guin's overall purpose because it shows that the citizens of Omelas have everything they could ever want right where they live; they just have to deal with the fact that their is a child locked away in a dark room suffering for their joy. In the beginning of the story, Le Guin questions the reader, asking, "Do you believe? Do you accept the festival, the city, the joy?" (4). After this question is posed, Le Guin finally exposes the truth about Omelas, that it is imperfect and corrupt. This situational irony encompasses the purpose of the story in that while everything may seem perfect, in order for society to function there must be someone or something that is suffering and others must selfishly ignore it. The actual child, who is only referred to as "it", symbolizes those like the poverty stricken people or the minorities that are discriminated against. Every person knows completely that they exist and they are struggling, but through selfishness they do nothing to change it. Arguing that people place their own happiness above the suffering of others, Le Guin demands change in this selfish world.

Monday, September 29, 2014

Literary Analysis: "Hills Like White Elephants"

      In "Hills Like White Elephants", Ernest Hemingway tells the story of a couple trying to make a life altering decision as they are waiting at a train station in Spain. Hemingway uses a manipulative conversation and specific symbolism to characterize the relationship between the characters and reveal the importance of communicating and being honest with a significant other. 

      Hemingway phrases the couples dialogue very manipulatively to display the poor communication between the girl and the man. The man frequently expresses how he thinks having the operation would be beneficial, stating, "I think it's the best thing to do. But I don't want you to do it if you don't really want to" (477). By the man not directly controlling the girl's decision but yet influencing her by constantly adding in his personal opinion, Hemingway is characterizing their relationship as devious and showing how the man has a lot of power over the girl. Through the use of symbols, Hemingway is able to display the lack of positive communication between the couple. The short story is titled "Hills Like White Elephants" and the girl mentions how the view from the train station looks like white elephants. The discussion of elephants symbolizes the couple's avoidance of talking about the issue and their true feelings because an elephant is often used as an expression to describe the large and obvious problem, but the two never actually address their "elephant in the room". Hemingway also names the girl Jig, but only refers to the other character as the man. By naming the girl Jig, which can mean a fast paced dance, Hemingway is symbolizing how the two dance around the issue at hand and try to avert the topic at all costs. Through these symbols Hemingway is characterizing the relationship as unhealthy due to their inability to address the issue and be honest with one another. Hemingway is revealing that it is imperative for people in relationships to be honest and share their true feelings, and not try to deceive their partner.  

Wednesday, September 24, 2014

Short Analysis: "I Stand Here Ironing"

        In the short story "I Stand Here Ironing", Tillie Olsen tells the story of a mother reflecting back on the poor choices she made while mothering her first child in a time of great stress and how this affected her child's life. Through the use of a reflective point of view, a regretful tone, and a conversational way of writing the author to show how ashamed the narrator is and reveals that many parents feel guilty about how their actions as parents affect their children.

        The narrator floods the reader with all of her thoughts to display how guilty she feels about the way she raised her first child. When discussing the daycare that the narrator makes Emily go to so that she can find work, the narrator states, "I knew Emily hated it even if she did not clutch and implore 'don't go Mommy' like the other children" (14). By reflecting back on her past thoughts and elaborating on them now, the narrator displays that she did not think she was a good mother for Emily and she continuously feels guilty about it. The narrator's final statement is, "help make it so there is cause for her to know - that she is more than this dress on the ironing board, helpless before the iron" (56). By leaving the reader with such regretful statement, the narrator is comparing her mothering of Emily to that of an iron ironing a frail, helpless dress. This statement displays the deep regret and shame that the mother feels about her choices, and uncovers that many parents feel this same regret about how they raised their children.

Monday, September 22, 2014

Exploring the Text: "Cathedral"

1. The first person narrator of "Cathedral" reveals himself to the reader through telling his wife's and parts of his own backstory, his thought process, and his reactions to Robert. By expressing concerns about having a blind man stay in his home and asking questions about the blind man such as "Was his wife Negro", the narrator demonstrates that he is not comfortable with the situation and also that he may not be tolerant of all people (12). The narrator also discusses his own actions, for example when he states, "Every night I smoked dope and stayed up as long as I could" (85). This remark, and his constant refilling of his drinks, portrays some of the narrator's more negative characteristics. With short, agitated sentences, the narrator's discomfort about the situation and comment about his own actions reveal that he is somewhat pessimistic and does not take care of his body.

2.  The narrator sets the reader up for a negative experience with the blind man. With judging thoughts such as "A beard on a blind man! Too much, I say", the narrator creates the expectation that this blind man will be bad company, and adds more evidence of his own unfavorable personality. The reader's first response to the blind man is not what the narrator has expected; the blind man is very polite and friendly. The narrator uses dialogue to create this experience for the reader. The blind man, Robert, first gives the narrator a firm handshake and jokes with him, and even when asked peculiar or irrelevant questions Robert is happy to converse with the narrator and his wife.

3. Blindness is most obviously addressed in this story through Robert's inability to see. The most impactful emphasis on Robert's condition is when he and the narrator are watching television and Robert does not know what a cathedral is. After failing to explain with words, the narrator draws a cathedral on thick paper while Robert holds over his hand. This cooperation and overall experience enlightens the narrator and enables him to see what he could not before; that living without seeing is difficult, but does not call for people to be treated any less than others. While at the beginning of the story the narrator harshly stated that, "his being blind bothered me", throughout their experience together the narrator realizes how truly difficult life must be for Robert (1). The narrator not only discusses the actual physical disability of being blind but also many peoples' lack of truth about the lives of those who are blind.

5. AT the end of the story, the narrator experiences a type of epiphany about the act of seeing, but the author never explains what this insight is. Carver withholds that specific information from the reader so that they can be left questioning what happens to the narrator and also interpret what they believe his epiphany was. Anyone who reads this story can take away a very different, but equally meaningful, meaning because Carver left the ending so unanswered. Many other important details are left out of the story, such as how the wife feels about the narrator's transformation, so as to keep that focus on the narrator and his newly discovered ideas. The background information about the narrator is also left out of the story so that the reader does not have any context as to why the narrator thinks the way he does.

6. The narrator and his his wife do not have a healthy relationship; they barely interact, they do not make healthy choices, and they do not support each other's actions or thoughts. The wife and narrator are never seen being affectionate towards one another and do not seem to be on the same page. This is exemplified by the narrator when he is describing his nightly habits and says, "My wife and I hardly ever went to bed at the same time" (85). Carver seems to be judging the couple by emphasizing how different the couple is in their actions and words. During the process of reading the story, I judged the couple for many of their actions and interactions. They do not seem to support each other and it appears as if they are bringing out the negative aspects of one another.

Thursday, September 18, 2014

Short Analysis: "Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been?"

            In the short story “Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been?” Joyce Carol Oates tells the story of a teenage girl named Connie who tries to escape the boredom of her family by fooling around but attracts the attention of an older man who becomes obsessed with her. Through the girl’s complaints about her family and behavior when dealing with the obsessed man Oates develops the main characters. With this characterization, Carol Oates uncovers the truth about adolescent sexuality and confinement.


            Throughout the entire story, Connie complains about her terrible family and tries to brake free from their judgment. With one of her friends, Connie starts going to a restaurant, meeting boys, and experimenting with her sexuality. Oates includes Connie’s constant daydreaming about these boys to demonstrate how teenagers are often fascinated with the opposite gender and the idea of sex. When Connie realizes that Arnold Friend, the stalker like older man, is a real danger she tries to call for help. Connie has a complete breakdown, and Oates describes the scene by stating, “She cried out, she cried out for her mother” (143). By having Connie call for her mother when she is too scared to have sex with this man, Oates is advocating that teenagers should not be having sex because they are too young and immature for such intimacy. Also, Connie frequently complains about how boring and annoying her family is, and on that day she refuses to go to a barbecue with them because, “she wasn’t interested, rolling her eyes, to let her mother know just what she thought of it” (12). Oates characterizes Connie as a self-proclaimed independent girl who does not need her family. But on the night Arnold Friend came to her house, Connie needed her family most of all. This ironic twist exposes Oates’ purpose of writing the piece: to illuminate that teenagers should not be completely independent and need the support of their families to survive.

Wednesday, September 17, 2014

Short Analysis: "The Yellow Wallpaper"

    The use and manipulation of setting can allow an author to create a specific tone and add to the plot of the story. In "The Yellow Wallpaper", Charlotte Perkins Gilman tells the story of a young woman suffering from a mental illness who tries to liberate herself from the overbearingness of those around her. Through the setting of the story, Gilman challenges the typical gender roles of 1892 and the stigma revolving around mental illnesses. 

The house in which the couple, John and the narrator, lives in is an old Victorian house that they are renting. The room where the couple sleeps has old, dingy yellow wallpaper on the walls. The narrator becomes enthralled with the pattern on the wallpaper and begins to believe that there is a woman trapped in it. This figment of the narrator's imagination is a symbol of the narrator; the woman trapped in the wallpaper symbolizes the narrator who is trapped in her house by her husband, who doesn’t allow visitors or her to leave. The narrator becomes obsessed with the woman stuck in the walls and locks herself in the room and violently tares the wallpaper off the walls.  John tries to get into the room and when he finally does he faints out of shock. The narrator, who was at this point walking around the room, stated; “Now why should that man have fainted? But he did, and right across my path by the wall, so that I had to creep over him every time!” (267). In the beginning of the story, when the husband told her what to do and to stay in the room was Gilman portraying the typical relationship in 1892. Gilman used the wallpaper in the setting to show how the narrator was physically and mentally trapped by her husband. By illustrating the narrator physically stepping over John, she is challenging normal gender roles and advocating for women to be treated as equals. Through the different details of the setting, Gilman challenges the ideas of gender roles in the 1890s.

The setting of this story also allows Gilman to reveal the truth about the stigma of mental illness. The room with the yellow wallpaper, which the narrator believes to have served as a nursery in the past, is set up like a room where mentally ill people would be held. The bed and furniture are nailed to the ground and the windows are barred shut. The qualities of the room combined with the narrator’s ignorance towards the room’s past functions display Gilman’s main argument; mentally challenged people are treated inhumanely and as if they are in prison. With such an imprisoning setting, Gilman argues for change in the treatment of those with mental illnesses.

In order to prove her overall purpose of challenging the typical gender roles and treatment of the mentally ill, Gilman uses setting and reveals her overall meaning.